News
Judge lets the RAM price-fixing lawsuit against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron go ahead
A federal lawsuit accusing Samsung, SK hynix and Micron of working together to limit memory supply will go forward. On November 14, US District Judge Noël Wise in the Northern District of California denied the three companies' joint motion to dismiss the case, known as Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics.
The ruling doesn't mean the companies did anything wrong. At this stage a judge only asks whether the complaint, taken as true, tells a believable story of a conspiracy. The judge decided it does, so the case now moves on to the slower work of gathering evidence.
Who is suing, and over what
The suit was filed on June 25 by 17 plaintiffs: 14 individuals and three small PC businesses, according to Tom's Hardware. They want it to become a class action on behalf of people who bought memory indirectly, through things like RAM kits and PCs, rather than buying chips straight from the makers. They're asking for an injunction and triple damages under US antitrust law, plus claims under the laws of five states.
The complaint argues the three companies moved in step to tighten supply. It points to production cuts starting in late 2022, a shared shift of factory capacity toward HBM (the stacked memory used in AI chips), all three announcing an end to DDR4 between April and June 2025, and near-identical customer screening questions adopted in January 2026. Micron's decision to close its Crucial consumer brand is also part of the story.
Together the three companies made more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025, LitNews reports, citing the complaint.
What the judge decided
The memory makers argued this was a rerun of an earlier case, known as DRAM II, which they won on appeal in 2022. They said AI demand, Chinese competition and ordinary business sense explain their choices. Asked whether the new case was simply DRAM II again, the judge wrote: "The Court finds that it is not."
The order found it plausible that the companies acted in parallel on supply cuts, the HBM pivot and the DDR4 exit. It also accepted several "plus factors" that courts look for beyond parallel behavior, including paused or delayed new chip factories and the matching customer vetting. Some of the plaintiffs' arguments didn't count: the judge set aside claims about DDR3, statements to investors, and meetings at industry conferences.
According to LitNews, the companies' answers are due by December 7, and the first case management conference is set for January 12, 2027.
Context: it has happened before
This isn't the first time memory makers have faced price-fixing claims. In the early 2000s several DRAM makers, including Samsung and Hynix, pleaded guilty to fixing prices between 1998 and 2002, and paid fines of $300 million and $185 million respectively. Micron received immunity in that case for cooperating. The new complaint leans heavily on that history.
What this means if you're buying RAM
Nothing changes at the store. Antitrust cases like this usually take years, and a ruling at this stage won't move contract or retail prices. If you've bought RAM or a PC during the shortage, it's worth keeping your receipts in case a settlement or class payout ever comes, but don't plan a purchase around it. For timing an upgrade, our guide on whether to buy now or wait is still the better place to start.
Sources
- LitNews, Judge refuses to dismiss DRAM supply conspiracy suit against Samsung, SK hynix, Micron (Nov 14, 2026)
- Order denying motion to dismiss, Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, N.D. Cal. No. 5:26-cv-06345 (Nov 14, 2026)
- Tom's Hardware, Samsung, SK hynix and Micron sued over alleged DRAM price fixing (Jun 29, 2026)